Original Sin, crime and punishment is the subject of Dr. Kathryn Paige Harden’s latest book. Its full title is Original Sin: On the Genetics of Vice, the Problem of Blame, and the Future of Forgiveness (2026). Paige self identifies as a “mother, scientist, and teacher”. Additionally, as a “classic Freudian neurotic who represses anger, intellectualizes it, turns it against the self. My therapist regularly, gently prods: ‘Are you sure you’re sad? Could you possibly be … angry?'” (p.202)
Notwithstanding – this is one of the smartest books I’ve read.
Dr. Harden (as yes – a classic neurotic*) also states: “I am not entirely defined by my race or ethnicity, or pattern of sexual attraction, or grades, or disability, or creed. Neither am I entirely defined by my genotype, nor by my behavior. Even my worst behavior. And neither are you.” (p.243-4) She also self-identifies as an atheist and egalitarian. And not the least – daughter.
Who is Kathryn Paige Harden?
That’s a good question. She’s the same age as my son. So she’s a Millennial, 44 years old. Paige is white, female, very attractive (in my opinion), and super smart. However, as such, none of those attributes were under her control. She didn’t choose them. (Chapter 6 is titled Choice.)

Nor did she choose to have grey hair at the age of forty-four. My son has zero grey hairs on his head, or face. Is the grey hair due to her genes? Her behaviors? Her career? … Or her neuroticism?
The list of attributes Paige didn’t choose is long. To include where and when she was born and to whom. Which brings me to the Essence (The title of chapter 7.) of why she wrote this book–her crime and her punishment.
The Crimes
Paige’s crimes were adultery and the rejection of Christianity. Her punishment was public shaming and humiliation by her mother. Who decided she (Paige) was”undesirable and unwanted”. (p. 130-1, 203) Paige’s subsequent response was going “no contact”; and writing this book. Also known as Retribution–the title of the 10th chapter of this book.
Paige’s Style as author and writer
I love the way Paige wrote this book–her voice and the format. She blended her story and experience with her academic research as a professor; as well as her work when a practicing Psychologist. Dr. Harden explains in chapter six, Choice, that this is known as “the Boulder Model”, of the training of a Psychologist. However, true to who she is – she says that model didn’t take with her. Subsequently, she quit practicing as a therapist.
[This book is so rich. In fact! that’s the style in which I write! I didn’t know it had a name.]
Dr. Harden’s Work
Dr. Harden’s work is focused on researching behavioral genetics. Which is a very unpopular field of study. Because it digs into the Christian idea of original sin and Christ as savior. Moreover, it challenges the idea of personal responsibility, or agency for ones behavior. Good and bad behavior.
IF our behavior is genetically determined, not chosen? What is the “just” Consequence (Chapter 9) for crimes such as rape and murder? Furthermore, IF our genes can now be known and manipulated? (They can.) What’s to stop people from engineering perfect babies? Also known as eugenics. Paige discusses these questions in the book.
I won’t give away her answers. I will say she says, “Hope can take many forms.” (p.247) Additionally, “There is no answer to the question of ‘why’ that will undo the past.” (p.248) And finally, “Most pieces of the Puzzle (The last chapter.), though, remain missing.
(p. 250)
Neuroticism
Neuroticism is one of the Big Five (OCEAN) personality traits. It (neuroticism), also, is a very unpopular subject. As is Freudian psychoanalysis and theory. Moreover, the notion that human behavior is determined is almost universally rejected. Freud was a Determinist, as am I. Dr. Harden speaks to this in chapter 12, Puzzle.
“If one is a committed determinist and free will skeptic, the crucial observation is that behavior is caused (emphasis mine); whether the causes are conventionally thought of as nature or nurture makes not one whit of difference.” (p. 245)
Freudian theory is that most behavior is motivated by the unconscious. In other words – asking a person why they did, or do, what they do is not useful. Because without probing their unconscious–it’s just a story, a fiction. I agree.
With that said, I’ll suggest to Paige, that her mother’s Christianity brings her comfort and meaning in a world that does neither.* Paige asks, “How can we maintain faith in goodness in a cruel, capricious world? Can we have hope for the future?” (p. 247) To Paige, belief in God is one way.
Furthermore, that Paige’s neuroticism might be an inherited genetic trait from her mother! Thus – therapy and change.
Change
Change is the purpose of therapy, not validation. It’s hard. Because sometimes we’re up against our genotype, our DNA. Our Essence. Moreover, to change is to admit that something’s wrong. That we might have made a mistake.
If we were born neurotic, contrasted to being born confident, what does that say about neuroticism? Why does such a condition exist? What does that say about the nature/nurture debate? What does that say about free will and determinism? God’s will? Or man’s plan?
Dr. Harden looks at all of these questions in this book. Additionally, how they are all tangled up in the notion of original sin, crime and punishment. And ultimately – the question of forgiveness. Can we change who we are? Furthermore, should we?
Conclusion
Paige is studying human genetics and if certain clusters of combinations of genes predict certain behaviors related to anti-social behavior. Or crimes. She posits that they do. However, she offers that we might not want to change such a genetic structure. The nature of things. Because, those structures can and sometimes do lead to great things for humankind!
I’d like to chat with Dr. Harden. Because I’ve decades of experience working within the construct of her questions. The questions of original sin, crime and punishment. What fun that would be, for me.
Should you read this book? Why not?
*My definition of “a neurotic” is someone who makes mountains out of molehills.
*I am not implying that all persons who believe in Christianity score as neurotic. However, most of us have some degree of neuroticism. Furthermore, that in some situations we all will make a mountain out of molehill.